Until the end
Nov. 22nd, 2004 04:23 pmHmmm. Have finally seen The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes with Basil Rathbone, and I can confidently say this is definitely the best of all the Rathbone/Bruce films. Starting a film off with Moriarty in the dock, and getting out of a murder charge on a technicality. Oh yes, very good. Though it was strange that everyone in the room was like, "My god, what a monster you are! Because we all apparently know the inner workings of your organisation!". But, well. 1939. And the banter between Holmes and Moriarty! Too bad Nigel Bruce has to act like, well, the way he does. Although he has a few fine moments (there's a very good one where he is lying in the middle of the street, and I swear Holmes only had him do it because he thought it would be funny). Basil Rathbone is still good, not tired of the role yet and merely going through the motions, and of course, having the film actually be set 1894 is quite nice. *ponders visual treat of Basil Rathbone wearing a high collar* Too bad he has to wear that dreadful hat at the end.
George Zucco is one of the best Moriarty's I've ever seen; this is like saying Edward Hardwicke is one of the best Watson's I've ever seen, in that most Watsons are rather unsatifactory, though not neccessarily bad. George Zucco, though, especially for a film of that time period, was quite good at playing Moriarty as quiet, smiling scholar, who also happened to be a sociopath. This was a fine passage between the professor and his butler (imagine Moriarty speaking very carefully, and the butler speaking with a note of rising panic in his voice):
"You wanted to see me, sir?"
"I am away for a few weeks, Dawes, and I come back to find my infurium magenta, my incomparable infurium magenta, withered. Ruined."
"I can't understand it sir, I took good care of all the plants."
"Did you water them?"
"Every day sir, just as you told me."
"Then how does it happen that I find a spider's web spun across the spout of the watering can?"
"That can happen overnight, sir --"
"Overnight, eh? Then you didn't water them today."
"There's been so much to do, sir, preparing for your coming back and --"
"Nothing is as important as the care of my flowers. Through your neglect this flower has died. You have murdered a flower."
"Why, I am sorry sir."
"And to think that for merely murdering a man I was incarcerated for six whole weeks in a filthy prison cell."
"A pity sir."
"A travesty on justice."
"Quite so, sir."
An underling questions Moriarty's plan to break Holmes by pulling off the most daring criminal act right beneath his nose:
"Holmes again?"
"Always Holmes, until the end."
...
George Zucco is one of the best Moriarty's I've ever seen; this is like saying Edward Hardwicke is one of the best Watson's I've ever seen, in that most Watsons are rather unsatifactory, though not neccessarily bad. George Zucco, though, especially for a film of that time period, was quite good at playing Moriarty as quiet, smiling scholar, who also happened to be a sociopath. This was a fine passage between the professor and his butler (imagine Moriarty speaking very carefully, and the butler speaking with a note of rising panic in his voice):
"You wanted to see me, sir?"
"I am away for a few weeks, Dawes, and I come back to find my infurium magenta, my incomparable infurium magenta, withered. Ruined."
"I can't understand it sir, I took good care of all the plants."
"Did you water them?"
"Every day sir, just as you told me."
"Then how does it happen that I find a spider's web spun across the spout of the watering can?"
"That can happen overnight, sir --"
"Overnight, eh? Then you didn't water them today."
"There's been so much to do, sir, preparing for your coming back and --"
"Nothing is as important as the care of my flowers. Through your neglect this flower has died. You have murdered a flower."
"Why, I am sorry sir."
"And to think that for merely murdering a man I was incarcerated for six whole weeks in a filthy prison cell."
"A pity sir."
"A travesty on justice."
"Quite so, sir."
An underling questions Moriarty's plan to break Holmes by pulling off the most daring criminal act right beneath his nose:
"Holmes again?"
"Always Holmes, until the end."
...