She had so much humour and ambition to give and ended up a selfish, emo-lovesick child who was completely ruined in TSE/JE. It makes me feel pity for her, and now I want to read good Rose fanfiction where she does start to move on and have that progress I always assumed everyone gained, eventually.
tSE/JE is just inexplicable to me. why would RTD write her like that? what about all the kids watching, the little girls, who started off with rose when they were eight or nine years old? referecing thoughts i have had elsewhere, i think he wrote a lot of that stuff in tSE/JE to wind up shippers/romantics -- the hilarious running toward each other forever scene and then getting shot by a dalek, then giving the not!doctor and rose a "happy ending" that is so artificial even the characters themselves seem weirded out by it. but how is that fair to rose's actual fans, those kids? jesus.
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
no subject
Date: 2008-11-17 08:53 pm (UTC)awwwwe.
She had so much humour and ambition to give and ended up a selfish, emo-lovesick child who was completely ruined in TSE/JE. It makes me feel pity for her, and now I want to read good Rose fanfiction where she does start to move on and have that progress I always assumed everyone gained, eventually.
tSE/JE is just inexplicable to me. why would RTD write her like that? what about all the kids watching, the little girls, who started off with rose when they were eight or nine years old? referecing thoughts i have had elsewhere, i think he wrote a lot of that stuff in tSE/JE to wind up shippers/romantics -- the hilarious running toward each other forever scene and then getting shot by a dalek, then giving the not!doctor and rose a "happy ending" that is so artificial even the characters themselves seem weirded out by it. but how is that fair to rose's actual fans, those kids? jesus.